Why You're Probably Charging Too Little (And What It's Really Costing You)

Updated on
Why You're Probably Charging Too Little: A brass balance scale weighing a few coins against a heavier bundle of handmade stickers, with the words "You're worth more than you're charging"

I've started more businesses than I can count.

I'm a serial entrepreneur, for better or worse. Over the years I've done drop shipping, phone cases, tumblers, jewelry, you name it. If there was a "make money online doing this" video, odds are I tried it. And I want to tell you about the part of all that nobody puts in the video, because it cost me real money before I figured it out, and I'd bet it's quietly costing some of you too.

Let me back up.

When I started in drop shipping, it had nothing to do with stickers yet. The pitch is everywhere and it sounds so clean. Set up a free Printify account, pick a product, slap your design on a blank phone case or tumbler, list it, done. And honestly, the setup part is true. Printify is free, there are plenty of suppliers, you can see their ratings, all of that works exactly like the videos say.

What the videos skip is when it actually costs you.

So picture me, brand new and excited. I rushed to build a website, bought a pile of mockups, paid for my monthly platform, set the whole thing up to look really nice, added my products, and started running ads on Pinterest and Facebook. Then the orders started coming in. Five, ten orders. A good problem to have, right?

That's when it hit me.

Say a customer orders five cases and it comes to a hundred and something dollars. Here's what nobody told me. The moment that order comes in, the supplier charges you to print it and ship it. They do the lion's share of the work, so they want their money right then. But the money your customer just paid doesn't reach you that fast. Your platform holds it and pays you out on a delay, usually a few days later. So in the gap between those two things, you're the one covering the supplier's charge out of your own pocket.

So there I was, brand new, bank account near empty, trying to figure out how on earth I was supposed to cover a hundred and something dollars for an order whose money hadn't reached me yet. I was robbing Peter to pay Paul just to get the thing made.

And here's the kicker. I'd go to these big creators with the slick "you can do this too" posts, and I'd ask, every single time, the same question. Why don't you talk about the money we have to float between paying the supplier and the platform actually paying us out? Either I got silence, or a "oh, good point, we'll look into that." And then nothing. No post. Not once. Ever.

That's when it clicked. They weren't lying, exactly. They just left out the part that makes it hard.

Now let's talk about the part you actually came here for. The pricing.

When you sell a case for thirty bucks, that number is not your money. The supplier takes their cut. Shipping takes a bite. Then taxes. Then your platform fees, your ad spend, the mockups, the monthly subscriptions. By the time all of that is done eating, what's left for you can be pennies on the dollar. And if you priced low to begin with, because you were trying to match some seller on Etsy or Redbubble or eBay who's somehow charging next to nothing, there's nothing left at all. You did all that work to make exactly zero.

And you can't out-cheap them anyway. You have no idea what their costs are. Maybe they buy in huge bulk. Maybe they already have inventory sitting in their house. Maybe they're losing money too and just don't know it yet. Racing them to the bottom is a race where the prize is going broke a little slower.

So here's the free, do-it-today nugget, the thing I wish someone had made me do before I ever listed a product.

Before you set a single price, add up what that product truly costs you. All of it. The supplier's price. The shipping. The platform and payment fees. A slice for taxes. And don't forget the cash you have to float before you ever get paid, because the timing on that depends on your platform and it changes now and then, so check how yours actually pays before you count on it. Write the real number down. Then price so there's actual profit sitting on top of it, the kind of profit you'd be glad to see. If the only way you can compete is to price below that number, then that product isn't a business, it's a hobby that bills you. Better to learn that on paper than the way I did, one painful order at a time.

I'll be straight with you, because it's the only way I know how to do this. I failed at the drop shipping stuff. Cases, tumblers, jewelry, one by one they put me in the poorhouse instead of pulling me out of it. Some people will read this and say I just priced wrong, or didn't hustle hard enough. That's fair. Maybe I did. But what I really learned was that the model itself wasn't for me, and no amount of grinding was going to fix the math.

So I went looking for something with low overhead. Something that didn't cost a fortune to make, didn't take over my whole house, and didn't make me front big orders before I got paid. That turned out to be stickers. They're light, they're cheap to produce, they're easy to order, and for the first time the math finally worked in my favor instead of against me.

I'm not telling you drop shipping can't work. Plenty of people make it work. I'm telling you to walk in with your eyes open. Know what you'll pay before the money comes back to you. Know your true costs cold. And please, don't price your work to match someone who's charging nothing, because all that gets you is two people making no money instead of one.

Charging too little doesn't just cost you dollars. It costs you time, energy, and eventually the whole thing, because nobody can keep pouring themselves into a business that pays them in pennies. That's the burnout I watched take out so many sellers I knew. They rarely said it out loud, but the math always told the story.

Price like your time is worth something. Because it is.

CEO & Founder

Hi, I'm Sonia. I run Piggy Print Stickers and built The Vessel Method to help other makers create brands that actually feel like them. I write from inside the work, not above it.

See the results for yourself

Before and After Results.

I spent years trying to build a cohesive brand and visual identity for my store PiggyPrint Stickers without having to become a professional designer overnight. I bought products that looked exciting on the outside. But when I opened them? Nothing. Just pages of information with no real path forward.
Before: Random Prompt
After: Vessel Metthod